GenoPro Home
GenoPro Home  |  Get Started With My Genealogy Tree  |  Buy  |  Login  |  Privacy  |  Search  |  Site Map
 

GenoPro Support Forum




Use of apostrophe-s in possessives

Click to view RSS...
Author
PEH
Posted Monday, January 16, 2006 - Post #9939
Junior Member

Junior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior Member

Customers
Gamma
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Saturday, May 4, 2024
Posts: 15, Visits: 65
I was horrified to discover that the beta GenoPro (unlike the 1.99b version) removes the final s in possessives for names that end is s. (Like: Les' family with Anne, Dennis' father was James.) This is not good UK English usage at all: it is far more usual to include the final s after the apostrophe for all names, even those already ending in s. I know that US usage is divided on this topic, but both Strunk and White's "Elements of Style" and the "Chicago Manual of Style" prefer this usage, as do Fowler's "Modern English Usage" and the Oxford University Press in the UK.

For endless discussion on this topic, see:

http://forum.wordreference.com/showthread.php?t=29285
http://www.bartleby.com/141/strunk.html#1
http://www2.ncsu.edu/ncsu/grammar/Apostro3.html
http://www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/dick/tta/wordpunc/wordpunc.htm
http://open-dictionary.com/%27s

etc.

This is so serious to me that I want to report it as a bug rather than as wish list item. Is there an easy way to customize this?
Posted Monday, January 16, 2006 - Post #9940
Legendary Master

Legendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary Master

Administrators
Moderators
Customers
Gamma
FamilyTrees.GenoPro.com
Translator
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Thursday, January 16, 2025
Posts: 4,886, Visits: 22,775
This is a known issue.  In the section New Report Generator - Translation and Grammar Issues, there are two posts that may interest you, both dealing with the possessive rules.
  1. Translation of Phrases in Dictionary.xml
  2. Translation of narrative phrases using pattern matching
PEH
Posted Saturday, January 21, 2006 - Post #9998
Junior Member

Junior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior Member

Customers
Gamma
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Saturday, May 4, 2024
Posts: 15, Visits: 65
Wow. That looks like a very powerful and elegant solution. I was quoting all the usage references because I thought I would have difficulty convincing you that there was actually a problem, but I now see that you have already embraced the problem and planned a "world-class" solution. I hadn't even thought of what would happen in non-English languages.

I presume that solution is still under development: at least I can't see any of the suggested tags in dictionary.xml, or am I looking in the wrong place?

When the beta is finalized, will there be a separate UK-English skin, with rules such as this one being specified differently from the default US-English one?
Posted Sunday, January 22, 2006 - Post #10003
Legendary Master

Legendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary Master

Administrators
Moderators
Customers
Gamma
FamilyTrees.GenoPro.com
Translator
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Thursday, January 16, 2025
Posts: 4,886, Visits: 22,775
The plan is to produce a flexible solution to generate quality reports. Eventually, one dictionary will be capable to inherit from another dictionary, so it will be possible to have UK-English and US-English reports with little extra work.
PEH
Posted Monday, January 23, 2006 - Post #10012
Junior Member

Junior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior Member

Customers
Gamma
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Saturday, May 4, 2024
Posts: 15, Visits: 65
I'm looking forward to the final dictionary support. But, for the moment, I fixed my immediate gripe by customizing the StrPossessiveProperNoun function in Lang.vbs.
Posted Tuesday, January 24, 2006 - Post #10016
Legendary Master

Legendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary Master

Administrators
Moderators
Customers
Gamma
FamilyTrees.GenoPro.com
Translator
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Thursday, January 16, 2025
Posts: 4,886, Visits: 22,775
PEH (1/24/2006)
I'm looking forward to the final dictionary support. But, for the moment, I fixed my immediate gripe by customizing the StrPossessiveProperNoun function in Lang.vbs.

You are welcome to post your code of StrPossessiveProperNoun.  I will update the master template with your code, so the next update has it.

Edited: Tuesday, January 24, 2006 by GenoProSupport

Posted Tuesday, January 24, 2006 - Post #10022
Legendary Master

Legendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary Master

Administrators
Customers
Important Contributors
FamilyTrees.GenoPro.com
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: 2 hours ago
Posts: 3,416, Visits: 26,379
PEH (1/16/2006)
I was horrified to discover that the beta GenoPro (unlike the 1.99b version) removes the final s in possessives for names that end is s. (Like: Les' family with Anne, Dennis' father was James.) This is not good UK English usage at all

It is some years (40+)  since I was last taught (UK) English language. However I have spoken to a few of my contemporaries and they agree that the rule taught at that time was to omit the possessive s for names that end in s. However, I for one would not be particularly perturbed to see it go either way. So let's keep freedom of choice. Cool


'lego audio video erro ergo disco' or "I read, I listen, I watch, I make mistakes, therefore I learn"
PEH
Posted Thursday, January 26, 2006 - Post #10038
Junior Member

Junior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior MemberJunior Member

Customers
Gamma
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Saturday, May 4, 2024
Posts: 15, Visits: 65
You are welcome to post your code of StrPossessiveProperNoun.

I'd be embarrassed to do so. It is quite a clumsy reversal of the test you do for a final s and ends up always appending the apostophe-s. Which is the way I want it: the essence of customization. I recognize that others (even on the east side of the pond) may prefer a different usage, in spite of the citations in my initial post, so I'm quite prepared to leave the master template the way it is so long as I have a work-around.

Ron: we must have learned UK English grammar about the same time. But we differ. This particlular usage grates on me like fingernails on a blackboard.
Posted Thursday, January 26, 2006 - Post #10039
Legendary Master

Legendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary MasterLegendary Master

Administrators
Moderators
Customers
Gamma
FamilyTrees.GenoPro.com
Translator
GenoPro version: 3.1.0.1

Last Login: Thursday, January 16, 2025
Posts: 4,886, Visits: 22,775
English is my second language... and I barely passed the [English] test to graduate Blush.  Grammar (both English and French) have always been my worse school subjects.
Posted Friday, January 27, 2006 - Post #10045
Famous Writer

Famous WriterFamous WriterFamous WriterFamous WriterFamous WriterFamous WriterFamous WriterFamous WriterFamous Writer

Customers
Important Contributors
FamilyTrees.GenoPro.com
GenoPro version: 3.0.1.5

Last Login: Saturday, March 14, 2020
Posts: 365, Visits: 3,680
Don't feel ashamed, I was useless in French when I was at school and had to give it up in order to get through the sciences !Crazy

It was only when I moved to France 26 years ago that I was at last able to get to grips with the language.Tongue



Similar Topics

Click to view RSS...
Expand / Collapse

Reading This Topic

Expand / Collapse
Active: 2 - 1 guest, 0 members, 0 anonymous.
Refresh
No members currently viewing this topic!